EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

New American Middle Consumer Research 

What Does the Data Tell Us?

What we once referred to as “Middle America” has morphed into a more complex, more diverse, and more fractured group of consumers that are unified by their common priorities and a sense of personal empowerment. At BMDG, we refer to this group as the New American Middle, and we know how they think, what they feel, and what they aspire to. We put them at the center of everything we do, always seeking to provide them with valuable experiences that are relevant to their lives.

Through our own research, we’ve discovered an essential truth about this large and valuable audience: the New American Middle is primarily motivated by values.

the research continues to confirm that values-driven brand expression is very (29.8%) or extremely important (21.8%) to consumers.

FAMILY FIRST

49%

rank family as the most important value when considering personal beliefs overlap with brand consideration.

RESPECT GROWING IN IMPORTANCE

41%

41% rank respect as the most important secondary value when considering personal preferences.

QUALITY #1 TRIGGER

50%

Almost 50% select quality as the most important purchase trigger.

BRANDS TAKING A STAND

25%

Only 25% don't think it's important for brands to take a stand.

80% believe it's somewhat, very, or extremely important that brands express their values and beliefs to its customers.

  • Family
  • Health and Physical Wellness
  • Spirtiualiy and/or Faith
  • Community
  • Environmental Stewardship and/or Sustainability
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100

PRIORITIZATION OF CONSUMER VALUES FOR BRAND CONSIDERATION

Rank these values in order of importance to you (rank from top[1] to bottom[5], top being most important, bottom being least important).

- 37.1% of respondents chose Health and Physical Wellness as the second most important value.

The female user has a higher preference for the Family value (by 5.5%).

- Spirituality/Faith is the most important value for the 45-54 segment.

1
2
3
4
5
  • Extremely Important
  • Very Important
  • Somewhat Important
  • Not So Important
  • Not At All Important
8
16
24
32
40

IMPORTANCE OF BRAND EXPRESSION ALIGNMENT

When you’re considering making a purchase, is it important to you that a brand clearly expresses its values and beliefs to its customers? (% distribution among respondents).

- Brand Expression alignment is most important for the 45-54 segment (61.5%)

- It's least important for the 55-64 segment (39.1%).

- The male user has a higher preference for alignment in Brand Expression (by 14.3%).

  • Quality
  • Price
  • Convenience
  • Brand Values
  • Customer Service
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100

PURCHASE CONSIDERATION PRIORITIZATION

What matters the most to you when you're considering buying something? (rank from top[1] to bottom[5], top being the most important and bottom being least important).

- Quality is top purchase consideration and is more important for the female consumer (by approx. 10%)

- Convenience is the least important purchase trigger.

- Brand Values is most important for 55-64 age group.

1
2
3
4
5

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR YOUR BRAND?

It means that in order for brands to be truly successful in this changed marketing landscape, brands that understand their why, their internal expectations and requirements and are able to express those externally in a way that meets the expectations of their consumers, those brands thrive.

Brand Requirements and Expectations
CORE VALUES
Consumer Perception and Experience

Brand Values Identification Positioning Framework: 

The New American middle is a consumer group that you no longer can afford not to speak to. This is our proven five-step process for identifying your brand’s economically sustainable path forward:

  1. Defining the operative set of values within your category

  2. Defining which values are core to your brand, and which values are currently being expressed though your brand’s marketing efforts

  3. Learning which values are owned, competed over, and shared by other brands in your category

  4. Identifying the “open space” in your category—which values the brands in your category are not currently activating around—as well as values over which there is unnecessary competition

  5. Developing a creative blueprint and brand playbook to fill that category “open space,” while also re-directing creative away from any wasteful values competition.

The outcome is a data-informed and stronger market positioning, a more precise visual identity and brand expression strategy, messaging strategy based on ownable values, customer relevance and resonance, and an audience prioritization blueprint. Foundation-ready brand strategy ready for activation.

FIND OUT MORE ABOUT THIS DATA-INFORMED BRAND EXPRESSION PROCESS